Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please 09:42 - Aug 9 with 3518 views | Blue_Heath | Would complete a fantastic window. Would rather see Kenlock given a chance than let Jonas leave for nothing at the end of the season and Garner is a Mick anti football type who we can do without. | | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:43 - Aug 9 with 3073 views | itfcjoe | If Jonas goes we'd have to get a replacement in | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:46 - Aug 9 with 3041 views | SomethingBlue | Kenlock for Knudsen is an unthinkably big downgrade, especially given our lack of experience elsewhere. I'd rather we weren't sucked into a relegation battle so on balance I'd go with comfortably our best left-back. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:46 - Aug 9 with 3032 views | Butterbing | Jackson looks done. If that is the last deal we should all be very happy with the business done. I would say any more are because of sales. I would argue that we need Knudsen and Garner's experience in the team (squad for Garner). Windass may only be done if Garner goes. If Knudsen goes we would need a replacement. Although, could be John as a loan which wouldn't need to be completed today. | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:49 - Aug 9 with 2996 views | JackSted | I don't mind losing Garner, as long as we get a decent replacement in. But I really don't want to lose Knudsen. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:50 - Aug 9 with 2986 views | itfcbam |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:43 - Aug 9 by itfcjoe | If Jonas goes we'd have to get a replacement in |
Agreed. Jonas is definately the better full back in a 4 man defence as Kenlock has tendency to get caught out of position. That said he is probably a better wing back. However Hurst prefers 4 at the back so therefore Knudsen is the better option. On top of that he can also play left centre back. | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:51 - Aug 9 with 2972 views | chicoazul |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:46 - Aug 9 by SomethingBlue | Kenlock for Knudsen is an unthinkably big downgrade, especially given our lack of experience elsewhere. I'd rather we weren't sucked into a relegation battle so on balance I'd go with comfortably our best left-back. |
Does/can Donacien play there? Sure I saw someone the other day saying he can play both FB positions. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:53 - Aug 9 with 2952 views | Darth_Koont |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:46 - Aug 9 by SomethingBlue | Kenlock for Knudsen is an unthinkably big downgrade, especially given our lack of experience elsewhere. I'd rather we weren't sucked into a relegation battle so on balance I'd go with comfortably our best left-back. |
Agreed. I like Kenlock although I'm not sure he's come on that much and seems to struggle a little defensively. Someone as solid and dependable as Knudsen will pay huge dividends to the team around him. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:53 - Aug 9 with 2952 views | Blue_Heath |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:50 - Aug 9 by itfcbam | Agreed. Jonas is definately the better full back in a 4 man defence as Kenlock has tendency to get caught out of position. That said he is probably a better wing back. However Hurst prefers 4 at the back so therefore Knudsen is the better option. On top of that he can also play left centre back. |
Jonas in a 3 I can do but he is a poor left back IMHO, gets a nose bleed on the half way line and easily beaten on the deck. His Naaridge exploits are clouding people's judgement! Kenlock is way better going forward and unless given a prolonged run we'll never know if he can improve. | | | | Login to get fewer ads
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:53 - Aug 9 with 2941 views | SomethingBlue |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:51 - Aug 9 by chicoazul | Does/can Donacien play there? Sure I saw someone the other day saying he can play both FB positions. |
He can but looks to me like a player who will need nursing into the Championship a little bit. Not a natural left-footer either. More of an emergency option in that role I expect, but useful to know he could if required. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:54 - Aug 9 with 2936 views | BloomBlue | Strange you want to give Kenlock a chance but not Morris by buying Windass. Morris is going to be the new Rhodes/Marriott he'll be leaving because of lack of first team chances | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:55 - Aug 9 with 2919 views | BlueBadger |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:53 - Aug 9 by Blue_Heath | Jonas in a 3 I can do but he is a poor left back IMHO, gets a nose bleed on the half way line and easily beaten on the deck. His Naaridge exploits are clouding people's judgement! Kenlock is way better going forward and unless given a prolonged run we'll never know if he can improve. |
'gets a nose bleed on the half way line'. With 7 assists last season? I'd say that was good for any left back, let alone one who never crosses the halfway line. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:57 - Aug 9 with 2903 views | Blue_Heath |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:54 - Aug 9 by BloomBlue | Strange you want to give Kenlock a chance but not Morris by buying Windass. Morris is going to be the new Rhodes/Marriott he'll be leaving because of lack of first team chances |
Wouldn't be averse to Morris but we need competition too specially up front where I fear we may struggle a little. | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:03 - Aug 9 with 2865 views | BlueBadger |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:57 - Aug 9 by Blue_Heath | Wouldn't be averse to Morris but we need competition too specially up front where I fear we may struggle a little. |
Without Knudsen, we'd be left with Kenlock. Who isn't really ready. And no competition. And a very new and somewhat inexperienced backline where I fear we would struggle. Or, exactly what you're worried about should Garner leave. [Post edited 9 Aug 2018 10:16]
| |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:06 - Aug 9 with 2843 views | Currie10 | I'm far from Knudsen's biggest fan however sorry Kenlock not for me in a month of Sundays. | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:08 - Aug 9 with 2819 views | chicoazul |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:53 - Aug 9 by Blue_Heath | Jonas in a 3 I can do but he is a poor left back IMHO, gets a nose bleed on the half way line and easily beaten on the deck. His Naaridge exploits are clouding people's judgement! Kenlock is way better going forward and unless given a prolonged run we'll never know if he can improve. |
And yet here he is with 7 assists last year and many chances created. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:11 - Aug 9 with 2809 views | Steve_M |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:55 - Aug 9 by BlueBadger | 'gets a nose bleed on the half way line'. With 7 assists last season? I'd say that was good for any left back, let alone one who never crosses the halfway line. |
Yeah, but they were all hoofs or something. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:16 - Aug 9 with 2791 views | BlueBadger |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:08 - Aug 9 by chicoazul | And yet here he is with 7 assists last year and many chances created. |
I've said this before and I'll say this again. 75% of people who want Knudsen gone are those who want him out because he said nice things about Mick. The rest are simply dimwits who still think it's 2015. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:19 - Aug 9 with 2770 views | Steve_M |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:16 - Aug 9 by BlueBadger | I've said this before and I'll say this again. 75% of people who want Knudsen gone are those who want him out because he said nice things about Mick. The rest are simply dimwits who still think it's 2015. |
Don't forget those who decided he was crap in his first season and won't let any amount of evidence change their minds. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:21 - Aug 9 with 2756 views | chicoazul |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:16 - Aug 9 by BlueBadger | I've said this before and I'll say this again. 75% of people who want Knudsen gone are those who want him out because he said nice things about Mick. The rest are simply dimwits who still think it's 2015. |
You may be onto something. I just don't understand how anyone can not rate Jonas. He is a great player! And also always seems so happy to be playing for us! | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:23 - Aug 9 with 2742 views | Reuser_is_God | Can’t see Knudsen going, unless we get a silly offer. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:24 - Aug 9 with 2735 views | Kieran_Knows |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:23 - Aug 9 by Reuser_is_God | Can’t see Knudsen going, unless we get a silly offer. |
It is deadline day in all fairness. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:26 - Aug 9 with 2723 views | moughm |
| |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:28 - Aug 9 with 2703 views | Darth_Koont |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:53 - Aug 9 by Blue_Heath | Jonas in a 3 I can do but he is a poor left back IMHO, gets a nose bleed on the half way line and easily beaten on the deck. His Naaridge exploits are clouding people's judgement! Kenlock is way better going forward and unless given a prolonged run we'll never know if he can improve. |
Sorry but I think that's nonsense. | |
| |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:30 - Aug 9 with 2681 views | Yallop |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 09:54 - Aug 9 by BloomBlue | Strange you want to give Kenlock a chance but not Morris by buying Windass. Morris is going to be the new Rhodes/Marriott he'll be leaving because of lack of first team chances |
If Morris bangs the goals in for the U23s he'll get his chance in the first team regardless of who we sign. The Championship is a long hard slog. | | | |
Jackson/Windass In Knudsen/Garner out please on 10:52 - Aug 9 with 2612 views | Guthrum | I'd rather have the use of Knudsen for a season than a relatively paltry fee now. His experience in defence, energy and enthusiasm could well be worth £1m to us over the next 45 or so games. It's not like we need to sell. | |
| |
| |