| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 21:27 - Jan 16 with 2314 views | TractorFrog |
This is the average rating given to each Ipswich player by EADT in every game of the season so far, the only exception being the 2-1 loss to Plymouth earlier in the season which I couldn't find an article for, so used the TWTD average instead, rounded to the nearest whole number. Here are the results, with the ranking emitted for those with fewer than five games played:
1. Cameron Humphreys 7.25 (16)
2. Sam Morsy 7.142857143 (28)
3. Cameron Burgess 7.117647059 (17)
4. Lee Evans 7 (23)
Zanda Siziba 7 2
Edwin Agbaje 7 1
5. Leif Davis 6.888888889 (27)
6. Sone Aluko 6.833333333 (12)
7. Luke Woolfenden 6.814814815 (27)
8. Conor Chaplin 6.8 (30)
9. Richard Keogh 6.8 (10)
10. George Edmundson 6.761904762 (21)
11. Christian Walton 6.703703704 (27)
12. Greg Leigh 6.7 (10)
13. Marcus Harness 6.62962963 (27)
14. Dominic Ball 6.625 (8)
15. Janoi Donacien 6.615384615 (26)
16. Kyle Edwards 6.571428571 (21)
17. Vaclav Hladky 6.571428571 (7)
18. Freddie Ladapo 6.533333333 (30)
Tawanda Chirewa 6.5 2
Albie Armin 6.5 2
19. Wes Burns 6.392857143 (28)
20. Kayden Jackson 6.37037037 (27)
21. Tyreece John-Jules 6.333333333 (21)
22. Kane Vincent-Young 6.235294118 (17)
Gassan Ahadme 6 (3)
George Hirst 6 (1)
Panutche Camara 5.666666667 (3)
Rekeem Harper 4 (1)
I think they do seem to have a bit of bias towards defenders for whatever reason, but even so having Cameron Burgess that high is surprising, and Wes Burns is very low but his contribution is perhaps a little overlooked in individual games because the opposition are so scared of him they tightly mark him and give more space for other players like Chaplin, perhaps. Janoi Donacien is also particularly low for a defender. Meanwhile Cameron Humphreys currently tops the pile for the second consecutive season (although last year it was with fewer than five games), but Sam Morsy is the highest ranked player without the boost given due to inexperience, which seems about right to me. I find it interesting to see how the players rank according to experts. |  |
| They'd all laugh at me if they knew what I was trying to do. To create a new strain of super-wine in half-an-hour with a fraction of nature's resources and a FOOL for an assistant. 'Bernard Black, he's mad,' they'd say, 'he's insane, he's dangerous.' Well I'll show them! I'll show them all! | | Poll: | What hurt more? |
| |  |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 21:35 - Jan 16 with 2227 views | Nthsuffolkblue |
This is one person or Andy and Stuart between them's view?
There is no way I would say that Humphreys has been our best player this season.
Another interesting analysis would be ppg for those matches the players have featured in. This will also be affected by the opposition played against but I think it would be a potentially revealing stat. |  |
| |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 23:08 - Jan 16 with 2031 views | HighgateBlue |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 21:35 - Jan 16 by Nthsuffolkblue |
This is one person or Andy and Stuart between them's view?
There is no way I would say that Humphreys has been our best player this season.
Another interesting analysis would be ppg for those matches the players have featured in. This will also be affected by the opposition played against but I think it would be a potentially revealing stat. |
Yes, long before stats were so widely generated and analysed in football in this country, in ice hockey in the States, there was always a metric called +/-, which told you the goal difference for the team during the minutes when a particular player was on the ice. More relevant for ice hockey I guess, where different lineups of players are coming on and off the ice throughout the game, but I still think it would be fascinating to see that sort of stat in football. |  | | |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 08:42 - Jan 17 with 1644 views | DJR |
The ratings for Jackson on TWTD are always far too low for me; can it really be said that he is only the 29th best player at the club? |  | | |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 09:09 - Jan 17 with 1595 views | itfcjoe |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 23:08 - Jan 16 by HighgateBlue |
Yes, long before stats were so widely generated and analysed in football in this country, in ice hockey in the States, there was always a metric called +/-, which told you the goal difference for the team during the minutes when a particular player was on the ice. More relevant for ice hockey I guess, where different lineups of players are coming on and off the ice throughout the game, but I still think it would be fascinating to see that sort of stat in football. |
Here is the ranking for ITFC on this - on net goals per 90 minutes played
Edwards
Burgess
Ladapo
Evans
Donacien
Harness
Aluko
Davis
Chaplin
Woolfenden
Morsy
Walton
TJJ
Burns
Edmundson
Jackson
Humphreys
Ball
Leigh
Camara
Vincent-Young
Keogh
Ahadme
Hirst |  |
| |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 09:16 - Jan 17 with 1565 views | TrumptonBlue |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 23:08 - Jan 16 by HighgateBlue |
Yes, long before stats were so widely generated and analysed in football in this country, in ice hockey in the States, there was always a metric called +/-, which told you the goal difference for the team during the minutes when a particular player was on the ice. More relevant for ice hockey I guess, where different lineups of players are coming on and off the ice throughout the game, but I still think it would be fascinating to see that sort of stat in football. |
I used to keep stats like these (I used goal average rather than goal difference) and would occasionally post them on here to widespread apathy, but the two main problems with them are that (1) a player's contribution is too easily and significantly skewed by a big win or defeat, and (2) the player who plays every minute - theoretically your best player - will by definition only ever have an average score and so will sit in the middle of the rankings. |  | | |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 09:19 - Jan 17 with 1541 views | GavTWTD |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 08:42 - Jan 17 by DJR |
The ratings for Jackson on TWTD are always far too low for me; can it really be said that he is only the 29th best player at the club? |
I think as a number 9, Jackson has frustrated a lot of fans especially earlier on in the season. |  |
| |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 13:52 - Jan 17 with 1345 views | positivity |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 21:35 - Jan 16 by Nthsuffolkblue |
This is one person or Andy and Stuart between them's view?
There is no way I would say that Humphreys has been our best player this season.
Another interesting analysis would be ppg for those matches the players have featured in. This will also be affected by the opposition played against but I think it would be a potentially revealing stat. |
i keep a tally of ppg (weighted to 1 for a start and 1/3 for a sub appearance)
obviously plenty of mitigations, but the top 5 in the league are:
ball (surprisingly! 2.36 pts)
john-jules
aluko
burgess
donacien
bottom 5 (without those playing 3 or less) are:
ahadme (1.67)
humphreys
kvy
keogh
ladapo |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 16:02 - Jan 17 with 1240 views | Jon_456 |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 13:52 - Jan 17 by positivity |
i keep a tally of ppg (weighted to 1 for a start and 1/3 for a sub appearance)
obviously plenty of mitigations, but the top 5 in the league are:
ball (surprisingly! 2.36 pts)
john-jules
aluko
burgess
donacien
bottom 5 (without those playing 3 or less) are:
ahadme (1.67)
humphreys
kvy
keogh
ladapo |
I was thinking last night about TJJ and the timing of his injury coinciding with our drop of form since Charlton.
Theres certainly been games since then where I felt his presence would have made a difference, specifically Wycombe away and Plymouth at home. | | | |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 16:14 - Jan 17 with 1211 views | SamWhiteUK |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 09:16 - Jan 17 by TrumptonBlue |
I used to keep stats like these (I used goal average rather than goal difference) and would occasionally post them on here to widespread apathy, but the two main problems with them are that (1) a player's contribution is too easily and significantly skewed by a big win or defeat, and (2) the player who plays every minute - theoretically your best player - will by definition only ever have an average score and so will sit in the middle of the rankings. |
Yeah, this seems like a nonsense measure to me. |  | | |
| East Anglian Daily Times player ratings 2022/23 on 17:12 - Jan 17 with 1135 views | USA |
And yet Burns is an unbelievable player for us right now I’m told on here!? | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
